Home / Storybooks / The Card That Would Not Stay Shuffled
The Card That Would Not Stay Shuffled
A Story Of Tarot

The Card That Would Not Stay Shuffled
A Story Of Tarot
A Salem Witch Shop storybook
1June's Aunt Delphine left her three things when she moved to Lisbon. A wool coat that was too big. A jar of buttons. And a deck of tarot cards wrapped in a blue silk scarf that still smelled like her perfume.
"Seventy-eight cards," Aunt Delphine had said, pressing them into June's hands at the airport. "Be polite to them. Ask good questions."
June had nodded as if she knew what that meant.
She learned the cards that fall the way other kids learned a video game. The Fool with his little white dog. The Tower with its lightning. The swords and cups and wands and coins. She kept the deck in its scarf in her top drawer and took it out every night.
2And every night, she asked the same question.
"Will Tess write back?"
Tess had lived two doors down for nine years. They had built a raft that sank and a fort that didn't, and they had walked the seawall to school together every morning. Then in August, Tess's family moved to Ohio, eight hundred miles from salt water. Tess wrote four letters in September, two in October, and none in November at all.
June had written five since then. She had them counted.
So every night she shuffled, and cut the deck, and asked. And every night, the card that turned over was The Star.
3She liked The Star at first. It was the prettiest card in the deck. A woman knelt beside a pool under a dark blue sky, pouring water from two jugs. One jug poured into the pool. The other poured onto the grass, where the water ran off in five little streams. Above her hung one great yellow star with eight points, and seven smaller white stars around it. In a tree behind her, a bird sat watching.
June looked it up in Aunt Delphine's little white booklet. Hope, it said. Renewal. Calm after a storm. Faith that things will heal.
"That's a yes," June said out loud to her bedroom. She slept well that night.
4No letter came the next day, or the next.
So she asked again. The Star.
She asked again on Thursday and shuffled longer this time, a full minute, until the cards went soft at the edges. The Star.
On Saturday she shuffled the way her uncle shuffled for poker, bending the cards into a bridge so they riffled together with a sound like a bird taking off. She cut the deck into three piles and stacked them backward. She dealt the whole deck out face down across her bedspread in rows.
One card, in the middle of the middle row, was face up.
She had not turned it over. She was sure she had not turned it over.
5After that, it happened every time.
June would shuffle and set the deck down, and The Star would be lying on top, face up, its blue sky shining. She would bury it in the middle and square the edges and look away for one breath, and there it was again. Once she found it face up inside the folded scarf, after she had put the whole deck away. Once she found it on her pillow.
It was not scary, exactly. It was more like someone tapping you on the shoulder and pointing, over and over, at something you were not seeing.
"I don't get it," June told the card. "You already said yes."
6By the second week of December, June was tired of The Star.
The mailbox was still empty. Every afternoon she ran the last block home from the bus, and every afternoon there were bills and catalogs and a flyer for snow tires. She started to resent the woman by the pool, kneeling there so calm, pouring water out as if it cost nothing.
One night she took The Star out of the deck and shoved it in the kitchen junk drawer, under the takeout menus and the dead batteries. She shuffled the other seventy-seven cards and asked her question.
The top card was The Star. Face up. A bit of rubber band was stuck to its corner.
7On Saturday June wrapped the deck in the scarf and walked down to the harbor, to the black and white shop with the brass bell over the door and the reading room in the back.
The reading room was small and warm and smelled like candle wax and old paper. A man with a gray beard and glasses on a chain sat at a round table, sorting a pile of cards by suit. A little sign in front of him said Mr. Pell, Readings By The Half Hour.
"I don't need a reading," June said. "I need you to tell me what's wrong with my deck."
Mr. Pell took off his glasses. "Let's see it, then."
8June told him everything. The question. The letters she had counted. The junk drawer. He listened without laughing, which she had not expected.
Then he shuffled the deck himself, slow and careful, and set it between them. He turned over the top card. It was the Six of Cups, two children in a garden, one handing the other a cup of flowers.
"Ask your question," he said.
"Will Tess write back?"
He shuffled again. The Star lay face up on top before his hands had even left the deck.
Mr. Pell made a small humming sound. "Well. That card has something to say. What number is The Star, June? And what comes right before it?"
9June knew this one. "Seventeen. It comes after The Tower."
"And what's The Tower?"
"Things falling apart. Something you built getting knocked down." She thought about the raft and the fort and the seawall. She thought about the moving truck in August, idling in Tess's driveway at six in the morning.
"So The Star is what comes after the falling," Mr. Pell said. "It isn't a yes, June. It isn't a no. It's not that kind of card. Look at what she's doing."
June looked. The woman by the pool. The two jugs.
"She's pouring," June said slowly. "She isn't waiting for anything. She's pouring it out."
10Mr. Pell nodded. "One jug back into the pool, to refill what runs deep. One onto the dry ground, so something can grow there. She's giving away what she carries." He tapped the card. "You've asked her the same thing every night for a month. I think she's been answering a different question. The one you didn't ask."
"What question?"
"You tell me."
June sat a long time with her hands in her lap. Outside, a truck backed down to the wharf, beeping. She thought about the five letters she had sent. Every one of them had asked Tess why she wasn't writing. Not one of them had said anything else.
11That night June sat on her bed with the deck in her lap and did not ask whether Tess would write back.
Instead she shuffled, and while she shuffled she said, very quietly, "What can I give?"
She cut the deck and turned over the top card.
It was the Page of Cups, a young person in a flowered tunic holding up a cup with a small fish peeking out of it. Aunt Delphine's booklet said a message, a gentle offer, a surprise of the heart.
June went through the whole deck, card by card. The Star was in there, near the bottom, lying face down like all the others. It stayed there.
12She wrote a letter that night, a sixth one, but it was not like the first five.
She did not ask why. She did not count anything. She wrote about the harbor freezing at the edges for the first time that winter, and the seal she saw sleeping on the town float, and how Mr. Pell had a beard like a gray scrub brush. She drew the raft that sank, with both of them on it, halfway under, mouths wide open. She wrote that she missed Tess, and that she hoped Ohio had at least one good hill for sledding.
At the bottom she wrote, You don't have to write back. I'll keep writing anyway.
13She walked it to the blue mailbox at the end of the seawall in the last of the light. The harbor was flat and pewter gray, and the cold made her eyes water. She pushed the envelope through the slot and heard it drop.
When she looked up, there was one bright point low over the water, steady and white, above the place where the sun had gone down. The evening star, her grandfather used to call it, though he always said it was really a planet.
June stood there until her fingers went numb.
At home, the deck lay wrapped in its scarf in the top drawer, all seventy-eight cards, shuffled, every one of them face down.
14The Real Practice Behind The Story
A traditional tarot deck has seventy-eight cards. Twenty-two of them are the Major Arcana, numbered from The Fool to The World. The Star is card seventeen and comes right after The Tower, so readers often see it as the calm that follows a hard change. Its usual meanings are hope, healing, renewal and generosity. Many readers suggest open questions, such as what can I do, rather than questions with a yes or no answer. They also say that asking the same thing over and over tends to muddy a reading. Tarot works best as a tool for reflection. It cannot predict what another person will choose, and it never replaces talking to someone you trust.
15The End
Next on the shelf is The Moon Jar.
Open The Next BookBack To The Shop16Where Our Name Comes From
Salem, Massachusetts, where most of the town's witch shops sit on or near the Essex Street pedestrian mall. We are an online shop, not a storefront there.




